BDS activists score win over Israel bonds in Trump’s Palm Beach

Palm Beach County’s investment committee rejects raising its Israel bond cap from 15% to 20% after months of pro-Palestinian protests, arrests and conflict-of-interest claims, limiting its ability to reinvest maturing funds

In the Florida county that is home to U.S. President Donald Trump’s Mar-a-Lago club, pro-Palestinian activists have scored a significant victory in their campaign against public investment in Israel.
Palm Beach County’s investment committee has rejected a proposal to raise the maximum share of its portfolio that can be invested in Israeli government bonds, following months of protests over what had become one of the most prominent U.S. public-sector investments in Israel since the October 7 attack.
פאלם ביץ'
פאלם ביץ'
Palm Beach
(Photo: Shutterstock, pisaphotography)
The decision is particularly striking because Palm Beach County, home to a large Jewish population as well as Trump’s Florida residence, invested a record $1 billion in Israel bonds in January, making it what local officials described as the world’s largest investor in the securities.
But as some of those bonds mature and the county must decide where to reinvest the proceeds, the political atmosphere has shifted. Israeli bonds worth $135 million matured on November 1, and under the current policy the county cannot simply roll all of that money into new Israeli bonds.
The investment drive began shortly after Hamas’ October 7, 2023 attack on Israel. Joseph Abruzzo, then Palm Beach County’s clerk and comptroller and now its county administrator, began buying increasingly large amounts of Israeli debt.
That same month, Abruzzo appeared at a synagogue in Boca Raton to announce a $135 million purchase as a show of support for Israel.
“Israel’s Finance Ministry needs this money,” he said at the time. “We are proud to make this investment, proud to stand with Israel.”
Within months, the county’s holdings in Israeli bonds climbed to roughly $700 million. In January, Abruzzo’s successor, Mike Caruso, announced another $350.5 million purchase, bringing the total investment to $1 billion.
County officials presented the deal as a financial success as well as a show of support for Israel. Caruso said the bonds were expected to generate around $136 million in interest over two to three years, about $23 million more than a comparable investment in U.S. government debt.
County leaders also argued that the returns could help reduce taxes for residents.
“My job is not politics,” Caruso insisted. “It’s about the safety of the investment, the availability of the money and the return.”
Critics, however, rejected the claim that the investments were purely financial. Pro-Palestinian activists launched a campaign called “Our Taxes, Our Needs,” demanding that the county stop lending money to Israel and instead direct resources toward affordable housing, public services and assistance for low-income families.
At one demonstration, protesters carried signs reading: “Money for wars, but no money to feed the poor.”
ההפגנות נגד המשך ההשקעות בישראל
ההפגנות נגד המשך ההשקעות בישראל
Protests against continued investment in Israel
(Photo: Social media)
Organizers argue that Florida taxpayers’ money is being used to help finance the war in Gaza. They also contend that the county is exposing itself to unnecessary financial risk by concentrating too much public money in bonds issued by a single foreign government.
Supporters of the investment counter that Israel has never defaulted on its bonds and that the securities offer higher yields than comparable U.S. alternatives.

Court battle and arrests

The dispute has already reached the courts. Three residents of Palestinian origin whose relatives were harmed during the war in Gaza sued over the county’s Israeli bond purchases.
They argued that the investment decisions were motivated by politics rather than financial considerations, in violation of the duties of officials responsible for managing public funds.
A Florida judge dismissed the lawsuit in July, in part because the plaintiffs had not established a sufficient legal connection between the county’s investments and the harm suffered by their relatives. The plaintiffs appealed.
At the same time, county commission meetings became increasingly confrontational.
In September, Palestinian-American legal scholar Noura Erakat was arrested after refusing to leave a meeting where protesters sought to speak about the Israel bond investments. She was charged with trespassing and released on bail.
Muslim and pro-Palestinian groups accused authorities of silencing criticism of Israel, while county officials said the hearing concerned the budget rather than investment policy.
Tensions flared again in October, when dozens of supporters and opponents of the Israel investments attended a county meeting and six participants were removed from the chamber by police.
Activists on both sides exchanged accusations, and one county official stressed that decisions over how public funds are invested are made by those responsible for managing the county’s finances, not by a public vote.

Investment cap remains at 15%

The protesters’ main achievement came on October 15, when the investment committee rejected a proposal to raise the permitted share of the county portfolio invested in Israeli bonds from 15% to 20%.
The change would have allowed the county to keep buying Israeli bonds as previous investments matured and money was returned.
According to figures presented at the meeting, Israeli bonds already accounted for nearly a quarter of the county’s investment funds, well above the limit allowed for new purchases.
In practice, the decision means Palm Beach County cannot automatically take money repaid by Israel and lend it back by purchasing new bonds.
Activists focused in particular on preventing the reinvestment of $67.5 million in early November. The county comptroller’s office confirmed that as long as the investment ceiling remains at 15%, it cannot buy additional Israeli bonds or renew investments as they mature.
ההפגנות נגד המשך ההשקעות בישראל
ההפגנות נגד המשך ההשקעות בישראל
(Photo: Social media)

Conflict-of-interest dispute

The makeup of the investment committee itself has also come under scrutiny.
One member, Norman Taplin, holds a senior position with Israel Bonds, the organization that markets Israeli government bonds in the United States.
The county commission approved his appointment despite that connection by granting an exception to its conflict-of-interest rules. Taplin recused himself from votes on Israeli bonds when a potential conflict arose.
The dispute has unfolded amid upheaval in the office overseeing the county’s investments.
Caruso, who led the record bond purchase in January, was suspended from office in August after being arrested and charged with sex offenses involving a minor, allegations he denies.
In last week’s election, he lost to Democrat Yvette Drucker, a former Boca Raton city council member.
But activists hoping for a broader pullback from Israel may be disappointed by the incoming officeholder. Drucker said during the campaign that she supports continued investment in Israeli bonds and opposes turning financial decisions into a political weapon.
In a questionnaire submitted to the local Jewish federation, she said she would not change her position because of activist pressure.
“I have received countless emails, calls and messages demanding that all investments in Israel bonds be withdrawn,” Drucker wrote. “I will not change my position because of their actions.”
Comments
The commenter agrees to the privacy policy of Ynet News and agrees not to submit comments that violate the terms of use, including incitement, libel and expressions that exceed the accepted norms of freedom of speech.
""