Repository navigation
PASS_WITH_CONDITIONS
Baseline. This re-reviews 6f612100 against the PASS_WITH_CONDITIONS on 363ad7e7 (this PR), on the same arch 42d214dc. The checkout has no arch-map.md, so I started from the lines the earlier rulings cite. No findings.json was staged. I checked that since.diff equals git diff 363ad7e7 6f612100 and that pr.diff equals git diff bea4ea72 6f612100. The compare is one merge of main (bea4ea72). It is clean: its tree c4a80303 equals git merge-tree --write-tree 363ad7e7 bea4ea72. It touches none of the PR's three files, and pr.diff is byte-identical to the diff of 363ad7e7 against its own main parent. The baseline ruling therefore stands for everything.
Governs: architecture.md AT25 (line 1756: the value never enters the box, and audit names store, id and authority, never the value). Also Gatehouse §6.10 (gatehouse-spec.md line 849: the audit event carries store, id, authority and decision), the min box audit reference (line 505), the Store Reference glossary entry (line 129), D6 (line 759), D9 (line 799) and the min secret reference (line 517).
Ruling. The box_connection span gets store and identifier only after an injection that happened. The values are the ones the audit record names, and the span never holds the value. The span is an addition to the audit channel, as D9 requires. The e2e case checks each AT25 mitigation that a box-side test can show. The three interims in the script (broker-scope spelling, proxy restart, no_sign_in gate) are labelled and link #2656 and #2746. The no_sign_in gate keeps a missing bep binary a failure for every signed-in case. The one open item is the e2e leg itself. It reports NOT RUN on this head, and rule 4 keeps it open as C1, filed on #2657.
Not checked. I did not compile or run the unit test or the e2e case. gh is not on this host, so I did not confirm that #2656, #2657 and #2746 are still open. I confirmed on this head that GrantSource still has no Store variant, so the #2656 interim is still accurate.
Conditions
- C1: Run
./scripts/session-e2e.sh bep_store_reference_end_to_endon the macOS lane that #2657 stages, with bep, the Keychain and MINVMD_GVPROXY_BIN present. The run must printKeychain secret by reference OK, not NOT RUN, and the run is recorded on #2657. Until then the e2e leg is open and the AT25 proof is not delivered.
Ruled at 6f61210 against gominimal/arch@42d214dc8ac8 by claude-opus-5-5; arch_rulings 603, job 60fa91b2-bb66-40a5-a216-c8ac301ca8e8.