Home » Commentary » Government says climate and energy reporting not “core news” of public interest – as dis-information runs wild

Government says climate and energy reporting not “core news” of public interest – as dis-information runs wild

Rooftop solar Melbourne suburbia small iStock-1213141547
NSW extends its energy savings plan so more renters and low-income residents can enjoy the benefits of solar PV, batteries and other energy efficient devices.(Image: iStock)

Renew Economy has been denied funding from the federal Labor government’s News Innovation Fund – not because others had a better idea, but because the government has decided that Renew Economy does not produce what it describes as “core news” that is of public interest.

The decision by the government was delivered via email a week ago and explained in detail a day ago by a senior department official after federal communications minister Anika Wells announced $35 million in funding for a variety of small and specialist publications.

We are stunned by the decision as it appears to misunderstand the importance of the climate and energy debate in Australian society, the role of our publication, and the specific proposal we set out in our application: Namely to combat the deliberate and widespread mis-information and dis-information in the public arena that clearly distorts these issues.

The department told us that “core news content is content that reports, investigates or explains: issues or events that are relevant to engaging Australians in public debate and in informing democratic decision making, or current issues or events of public significance for Australians at a local, regional, state or national level.”

It says Renew Economy does not meet that criteria. We argue that this is exactly what Renew Economy does.

Renew Economy covers climate policies and the green energy transition, including the switch to renewables, electrification, EVs, the changing grid, social licence and particularly the impact on consumers and the general public, which – as everyone knows and understands – is considerable.

We report in detail on the industry because only by understanding the industry can we, and our readers, properly understand the issues – and it is a lack of understanding of those issues that has been the principal failure of so-called “mainstream media” when they address these subjects.

That’s why we choose not to hide our content behind a paywall and why we make our content – written and produced by some of the country’s most experienced journalists – freely available to all.

The success and importance of this strategy is revealed in our readership data. Yes, we have nearly 30,000 subscribers to our daily newsletter, many from industry, and also from government, businesses and individuals.

But, more significantly, an average of more than half a million unique visitors come to our site each month to read our news and analysis.

The department appears not to understand what our role is, nor what our proposition entails. At a time of massive amount of misinformation, the government fails to understand the importance of this issue to Australians, and the importance of small media publications like Renew Economy.

“We have assessed that your primary purpose is the provision of news, analysis and commentary relating to the renewable energy and energy transition sector, which doesn’t meet the core news content definition relating to public debate or public significance used under this grant opportunity,” we were told by the department in an email.

“We assessed your primary audience being centred on energy, decarbonisation, and associated industries, rather than a general public community.”

We do not begrudge the other winners, many of which are worthy and some, like us, which are specialists in their own field and focus on particular areas of public interest. You can find a lists of the winners here.

But we argue that climate and energy is a fundamental issue to every Australian. And, because of the change in technologies in the past decade, nearly every Australian is part of of the energy industry in some form because they own rooftop solar, rooftop batteries, and electric vehicles, and are affected by their monthly or quarterly energy bills.

Just as an example: One third of all Australians have rooftop solar on the roof, and most of the rest possibly wish they could. That is a large and general public community. Every single Australian has been affected by electricity and fuel bills, all central to the debate around climate and energy policies and technologies.

The complexity of these issues is precisely why specialist, independent journalism is needed. A publication’s expertise in a particular field should not disqualify it from supporting informed public debate. On the contrary, that expertise can make an essential contribution to it.

The issues around energy and climate affect everyone. It is why there is such a massive campaign – funded by the fossil fuel industry – that underwrites the deliberate mis- and dis-information that is rampant in our media – both mainstream and social – and in our public debate.

Our proposal sought support to establish a “climate and energy integrity desk,” effectively to expand our current work and help address those issues identified in the government’s own Senate inquiry on mis- and dis-information.

You can see some reports emerging from that public inquiry here and here. An example : ‘Sloppy’, ‘misleading’, and funded by whom? Anti-renewable group under fire at Senate misinformation inquiry

But it seems that the government is incapable of recognising the importance of this. It has not yet provided an official response to the damning findings of the Senate inquiry, and the misinformation and disinformation in our mainstream and social media continues unabated and on a daily basis.

The federal government has yet to develop climate and energy policies that effectively address the climate crisis and the Paris climate treaty it has signed up to.

Algorithms – particularly on social media platforms such as Facebook and X – deliberately steer readers away from green energy information and prioritise fossil fuel talking points. AI is effectively stealing news by providing summaries that keep many readers away from the original source.

We will continue to do this important work – because we and many others consider it critical for the future of Australia’s economy and for the general community, our children and future generations. It is why we recently added former Guardian and SMH journalist Peter Hannam to our team.

As minister Wells says in her own release trumpeting the funding allocation: “The news and media sector is evolving at a rapid pace and publishers need support to be able to innovate, adapt and continue delivering the news their communities rely on.”

Indeed. We will appeal this decision and we will continue to pursue other means to support this important work. The “algorithms” designed by social media billionaires – few of whom seem supportive of the green energy transition – and the theft of our work by AI makes this increasingly challenging.

But we will seek to prevail – as we have done over the past 15 years (our anniversary is January 28, 2027). If you are minded to support our work, please click here. Your contribution will be very welcome.

To join more than 29,000 others and get the latest clean energy news delivered straight to your inbox, for free, click here to subscribe to our free daily newsletter.

To support independent media, and help combat the spread of deliberate misinformation and disinformation about the energy transition, you can click here to make a one off donation or become a regular supporter of Renew Economy.

Giles Parkinson is founder and editor-in-chief of Renew Economy, and founder and editor of its EV-focused sister site The Driven. He is the co-host of the weekly Energy Insiders Podcast. Giles has been a journalist for more than 40 years and is a former deputy editor of the Australian Financial Review. You can find him on LinkedIn and on Twitter.

Related Topics

17 Comments